Admiral’s InnTYBEE ISLAND
All Posts

Listicle

Updated 5 min read

The 7 Best Seafood Restaurants Near Tybee Island

Tybee sits at the mouth of the Savannah River, and the restaurants that know what to do with Georgia shrimp are worth finding. A ranked list of the seven we'd actually send you to.

Edited by Chirag Tailor

Aerial view of Tybee Island coastline and marsh

Tybee Island sits at the mouth of the Savannah River. Georgia shrimp are a seasonal catch here. The season opens in June and closes at the end of December, and the state sometimes extends it into the new year. So the best time for local shrimp is roughly June through December.

A handful of island restaurants do seafood well. Here are the seven we'd send you to, from the island itself out to Savannah.

How we chose

We kept it to places we'd recommend to a friend staying at the inn. Every spot on the list is open and serves seafood.

Four of the seven are on the island. Bubba Gumbo's and The Crab Shack are a short drive away. The Olde Pink House is in Savannah.

One note on timing. Many Tybee kitchens close around 9 or 10 PM, so plan dinner early. Hours change with the season, so check each restaurant before you go.


1. Sundae Cafe

304 1st Street. Dinner only, closed Sunday. Reservations recommended.

Our top pick on the island. It's a small, family-owned spot near the island entrance. It looks plain from the outside. Inside, you get Southern coastal cooking.

The place started as an ice cream deli, and it grew from there. Today it's a date-night favorite.

If you want a seat on a Friday or Saturday night, book ahead. Without a booking, go early and plan on a wait. It opens at 4 PM, Monday through Saturday.


2. Bubba Gumbo's

At the Lazaretto Creek marina, about ten minutes by car from the inn. Lunch and dinner. Walk-in. Closed Tuesdays.

This is Cajun-leaning seafood right on the water. It sits at the Tybee Island Marina on Lazaretto Creek, which is the island's working shrimp-boat marina. You'll drive here, not walk.

The signature dish is the seafood gumbo with andouille. The menu also has po'boys. The covered creekside porch is the place to sit.

The kitchen closes around 9 PM, and hours shift with the season. It's a good pick for an easy lunch or an early dinner.


3. Pier 16 Seafood

1601 Inlet Avenue, near the pier and South Beach. Lunch and dinner.

Pier 16 is about one block from the beach. It's a sit-down restaurant with casual seafood, burgers and salads. It isn't on the pier itself, but it's close.

The bar setup is a big part of the draw. There are two full-service bars, plus a rooftop bar, and the menu has signature cocktails. The rooftop deck looks out over Tybrisa Street.

It's the easiest stop on this list if you're staying near the pier. The kitchen usually winds down around 9 or 10 PM.


4. The Crab Shack

40 Estill Hammock Road, on Chimney Creek, off US-80 just before you reach Tybee. Lunch and dinner. Walk-in.

This one is technically off the island, but it has a Tybee address. The Crab Shack is a low-country seafood experience as much as a restaurant. The setting is a small hammock on Chimney Creek.

The signature dish is the Low Country Boil. The other draw is the Gator Lagoon, where you can see live alligators. Parking is free. It opens daily around 11:30 AM. Hours change, so check before you go.

There are no reservations. Walk in and put your name down. If you want ice cream after the meal, Leopold's is served here. It's the only place on Tybee that sells it.


5. North Beach Bar & Grill

33 Meddin Drive, North Beach, by the lighthouse. Lunch and dinner. Walk-in.

This is the practical pick when you're already at the north end. Maybe you just climbed the lighthouse or spent the morning at North Beach. You don't have to drive the length of the island to eat.

The menu is Caribbean and Southern coastal. It's a casual place, and it's open for both lunch and dinner. If the lighthouse is on your morning plan, build lunch in here.


6. StingRay's on Tybee

1403 Butler Avenue, about a block from the inn. Lunch and dinner, with late-night hours too. Walk-in.

StingRay's serves seafood and American food. It has a full bar and a big deck with umbrellas. There's live music too.

It's the closest seafood stop to the inn. You can walk there. It's also one of the places that runs later than most kitchens on the island. Check the schedule for live music before you plan your night.


7. The Olde Pink House (Savannah)

23 Abercorn Street, on Reynolds Square. About half an hour from the inn. Dinner. Reservations recommended.

The Olde Pink House is an 18th-century mansion. Its own site is theoldepinkhouserestaurant.com.

Inside you'll find candlelit rooms and a place called Planters Tavern. It's more formal than anywhere on Tybee, so dress for it. It's a special-occasion dinner for the night you want to leave the island.

If you want a second Savannah name, The Grey is at 109 Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard. It sits in a restored 1938 Art Deco Greyhound bus terminal. It's seafood-forward. Reservations are recommended: see its own site.


Honorable mentions

Mi Vida at 1315 Butler Avenue is not a seafood restaurant. It's a small, health-forward cafe about a five-minute walk up the street from the inn. Think açaí bowls, avocado toast and smoothies. It closes early in the afternoon and is closed on Wednesdays.

The pier area has a few counter-service spots near the end of Tybrisa Street. They're fine for a quick bite after the beach.


The summary

Sundae Cafe is our pick for a sit-down meal. Pier 16 is the easy choice near the pier. StingRay's is the closest to the inn. Bubba Gumbo's is the one to drive to when you want to eat by the creek where the shrimp boats work.

The Crab Shack and North Beach Bar & Grill are situational picks. The Crab Shack is for a loud, messy, low-country meal. North Beach is for the end of the island by the lighthouse. The Olde Pink House is for the night you want something different.

For the rest of the island, from breakfast to dinner, see our guide to Tybee Island restaurants. The dining page lists the places we send guests first. If you're still planning the trip, check availability here.

FAQ

Common questions.

What is the best seafood restaurant on Tybee Island?

Our top pick is Sundae Cafe at 304 1st Street. It's a small, family-owned spot with Southern coastal cooking. It serves dinner, and reservations are recommended.

Where can I get fresh Georgia shrimp near Tybee?

Georgia's shrimp season opens in June and runs through December. It is sometimes extended into January or later. Lazaretto Creek is the island's working shrimp-boat marina, and Bubba Gumbo's sits right there. Order the seafood gumbo with andouille or a po'boy.

Are there waterfront seafood restaurants near Tybee Island?

Yes. Bubba Gumbo's is at the Lazaretto Creek marina, with a covered creekside porch. The Crab Shack is on Chimney Creek, just off US-80 before you reach the island. Pier 16 has a rooftop deck near the pier, and StingRay's has a big umbrella deck about a block from the inn.

Is The Crab Shack worth it near Tybee?

For the full experience, yes. It's at 40 Estill Hammock Road on Chimney Creek. It's known for its Low Country Boil and its Gator Lagoon. It takes walk-ins only, parking is free, and it opens daily around 11:30 AM for lunch and dinner.

How far is Savannah from Tybee Island for a seafood dinner?

It's about 18 miles, or roughly half an hour, from the inn. Reservations are recommended at The Olde Pink House and The Grey.

Planning a trip to Tybee?

We’re one block from the beach and one block from the pier.

Check Availability

More places to stay on Tybee

From the same family of island hotels.

Book Now